Let’s start with the truth: estate planning is family work. It answers three core questions in plain English:
- What about me? Who protects my health, finances, and dignity if I can’t? Who has the keys, medical, financial, and digital, and how do they use them?
- What about my stuff? How do I avoid probate and make tax-savvy choices?
- What about my people? What options do I have to distribute assets in a way that honors relationships, promotes harmony, and acknowledges very real frailties?
The holidays are a rare moment when most of the people you love are under the same roof. Use 20 minutes before dessert to prevent years of confusion, resentment, or expensive emergencies. The goal isn’t to control anyone. It’s to lower the temperature, preserve dignity, and make tomorrow gentler.
A Personal Note: Jonah’s Whale
My parents have a whole bunch of stuff. We’re a nostalgic family. We know where they got all of it, and which pieces came from a chain store “just to fill a wall.” If you’re going “home” this season, look around and quietly sort items into two buckets: valuable and meaningful. Ask: What will people fight over? What tells our story?
In my family, it’s a glass figure: a whale with Jonah inside, holding a fishing pole. My brother and I are both obsessed with it. We’re not fighting about glass. We’re arguing (lovingly) about belonging.
I also need to source a glass artist who can make us another one (maybe with Pinocchio inside!)
Don’t Cut Them Off (When a Child Is Struggling)
If your adult children don’t get along, you are not alone. Many of my clients wrestle with the “right” choice: Disinherit the “problem child?? Put the “good daughter” in charge? What is fair? Here’s the hard news: it’s unlikely your passing will heal their relationship. It may leave your other children feeling financially responsible.
The holidays can be a tough, but appropriate time, to meet with the family to discuss fears and expectations.
A fully disinherited person has nothing to lose by suing. That invites stress, delay, fees, and broken relationships. Instead of scorched earth, use structure:
- Independent (neutral) trustee. Not a sibling enforcer. Neutrality lowers the temperature and keeps decisions on rails. A client was once named the successor trustee for her sister’s trust. She called me in a panic and said, “My sister is going to hate me.” She had no idea that she did not have to serve – she could decline the position. She did decline, and now enjoys a better relationship with her troubled sister.
- Discretionary trust with spendthrift terms. Creditor/predator protection, tailored support. Maybe a child has gambling or alcohol problems. Creating a trust to support them – health insurance, food, recovery programs – could go a long way to protecting them and their relationships with their siblings.
- A real no-contest clause with a meaningful stake (not $1). I don’t know where this “Leave them a dollar” nonsense came from, because it is much older than TikTok! It does not work.
- Behavior-aligned supports. Treatment-aligned distributions or matched/earned distributions tied to work or school milestones.
- Explain your “why.” A compassionate Letter of Intent helps your trustee administer firmly and with empathy.
- Consider a separate share trust: This maintains privacy for all siblings.
Bottom line: Appointing one warring sibling as trustee can turn grief into warfare. Appointing all three as co-trustees is never a good idea. Choose a neutral trustee and protect all your children—from each other and from the system. Think about what your estate plan can do to provide support to all of your children.
Talking to Mom & Dad (Without Making It About Money)
Keep it about dignity and choices, not assets.
- 20-minute agenda
- Who makes health decisions (AHCD) and financial decisions (DPOA) if needed
- Where do the documents live; who can access them (HIPAA release; digital access plan)?
- What must be honored—rituals, faith, or cultural preferences?
- Avoiding Court: If your parent loses capacity, you might have to resort to the courts for authority to manage their assets – file their taxes, pay their bills, negotiate their medical bills, and so much more.
Scripts:
- “We’re not trying to control anything—we want to honor your wishes and avoid panic.”
- “Who should hold your keys—medical, financial, and digital—if you can’t?”
Will You Be “The One”? (Caregiver Protection Plan)
If you’ll be the caregiver, your health and boundaries belong in the plan. Loving someone should not break you.
- Authority + access: AHCD, DPOA, and a HIPAA waiver for instruction and authority.
- Respite & back-ups: Build a schedule and fund it. Name alternates if you get sick.
- Reimbursements: Travel, lost wages, childcare, home modifications—spell it out in the trust.
- The first 48 hours: A one-page Care Team Card (contacts, meds, insurance, access).
Script: “I want to help, and I need a plan that keeps me whole.”
Trustee Choices When Siblings Don’t Get Along
Estate planning is about family dynamics, not just spreadsheets. You have options:
- One revocable trust—with clarity. If gifts are not equal or are distributed differently (e.g., outright distributions vs. holdbacks), include language that explains why. A short, values-based explanation helps beneficiaries understand you, and it helps your trustee hold the line.
- Multiple trusts: Powerful for privacy and tailored support. Each beneficiary’s share is administered independently—less cross-monitoring, fewer “you always…” accusations.
- Neutral trustee. Keeps decisions on time, on record, and on budget.
Critical: Ensuring that all your assets are properly titled with correct beneficiary designations is non-negotiable. Failure to fully fund the trust is how families slide into probate and open the door to litigation.
Story Night: Heirlooms Without Arguments
I loved the scene in Succession where the children are putting Post-it notes on their deceased father, Logan Roy’s, things. This is exactly what some families do.
A great way to get clarity about the “things” in your parents’ home, and to introduce the younger generation to the stories that things carry, is to try storytelling.
Fast format: 5 items • 5stories • 5 labels.
- Tell the story aloud.
- Label the recipient?
- Take a photo of the item and the label; save it with the plan.
Scripts:
- “You’re not getting a ring, you’re getting our history.”
- “I want you to have this because it reminds me of who you are.”
Prop 19 & the End of Family Gatherings? (Keeping Mom’s House—On Purpose)
If the house is the heart of your holidays, keeping it requires careful estate planning. California’s property tax rules can turn “let’s keep Mom’s house” into a tax shock and a forced sale. Before you promise anyone anything, understanding the implications is critical.
- Buyouts: Expecting that your children will “buy each other out” usually leads to the kids selling the house. Why? Transfer tax, income tax, and property tax reassessment.
- Who wants to live in the home? You might be surprised!
- Option to purchase from the trust? If your estate is mainly comprised of the home, can one child get a mortgage to purchase the home from your estate?
- What if they own it together? How would the child who does not live there cash out?
- Equalization: For siblings who won’t co-own, define cash equalization or buy-out terms.
Script: “We’re protecting the place that keeps us together—without sacrificing anyone’s fairness.”
Practice tip: Make sure you understand not only what Prop 19 says but how your local recorder/assessor’s office interprets Prop 19. It is still very much a wild card.
Blended Family Peace Terms (Love Everyone, Lose No One)
Clarity beats promises. Is it appropriate to create a marital trust that includes gifts for children from a prior relationship? Sometimes yes, and sometimes no.
- Separate share trusts for privacy.
- “Mommy/Daddy gifts” for sentimental items promised to children from prior relationships, and to leave money so that they are not “waiting” for the new spouse to die.
- Align plans with the other parent of your children—without alignment, your plan can unravel.
- Retirement Accounts: Don’t forget about these! Surviving spouses get better tax treatment – and these accounts generally are not trust assets.
Script: “Everyone is seen. Everyone is safe.”
Five Things to Think About Before Dessert
- Decision Keys: Who acts for health and finances? Do they know where documents are and how to access them (including digital)?
- Trustee Fit: Would a neutral trustee spare your kids a lifetime of resentment and legal bills?
- The House Plan: If the home is sacred, run the tax math before promises.
- Caregiver Bill of Rights: Put respite, reimbursements, and back-ups in writing—protect the helper.
- Meaning Over Money: Do Story Night now so the “why” is recorded and fights over heirlooms never start.
Kitchen-Table Scripts
- Opening line (parents to adult kids): “We’re doing this to avoid panic. Here’s what we want if there’s a health event.”
- Adult kids to parents: “We want to honor your wishes. Who should hold your medical, financial, and digital keys?”
- For a struggling relative: “This isn’t punishment. These boundaries keep everyone—including you—safer.”
- For sibling dynamics: “We chose a neutral trustee so none of you has to police the others.”
- For heirlooms: “You’re not getting a lamp—you’re getting our story. We’re labeling things so meaning leads—not market value.”
- For the house: “We’re protecting the place that keeps us together—and making it fair for everyone.”
FAQ (California-Aware)
Q1: Should I disinherit the “trouble maker”?
Usually not. Disinheritance often fuels litigation. A discretionary trust with an independent trustee, spendthrift protection, and a real no-contest clause sets boundaries without lighting a fuse.
Q2: Is it ever okay to name a child as trustee?
Yes—if they’re truly neutral, detail-oriented, and respected by siblings. But when siblings don’t’ get along a neutral professional trustee is usually the peace-preserving choice.
Q3: What’s the advantage of multiple trusts or separate shares?
Privacy and fit. Each beneficiary’s share is administered independently, which reduces surveillance, gossip, and conflict. It also lets you tailor support (e.g., staged distributions vs. long-term discretionary management).
Q4: Our gifts aren’t equal. Should we say why?
Yes. Include brief explanatory language in the trust and/or a Letter of Intent. It helps beneficiaries understand you and helps the trustee administer without second-guessing.
Q5: Our plan failed because an account bypassed the trust. What happened?
It wasn’t funded correctly. Title assets to the trust and align beneficiary designations. Stray assets lead to probate, delays, and disputes.
Q6: What should my 18+ kids sign?
At minimum: Advance Health Care Directive, HIPAA authorization, and a Durable Power of Attorney. Emergencies are where these shine.
Q7: Can we require treatment or sobriety for a struggling beneficiary?
You can align distributions with treatment and require third-party verification, while keeping clinical decisions with providers (not the trustee). Draft with care so it’s enforceable and humane.
Q8: Can we promise to keep Mom’s house?
Not before you model Prop 19/property tax impact and cash flow.
Q9: Is leaving $1 a good deterrent to contests?
No. That’s folklore. Pair a no-contest clause with a meaningful and maybe conditional gift and tight drafting.
Q10: Where should documents live, and who gets what?
Originals in a safe place; scanned copies shared with decision-makers. Provide first-48-hours instructions, contact info for your attorney, and digital access steps (password manager emergency access or named digital fiduciary).
Patricia De Fonte | De Fonte Law PC
Estate Planning with Heart®
LinkedIn | YouTube | Sign Up for Our Newsletter
